Library of Congress vs. National Archives Smackdown

The Library of Congress (LOC) and the National Archives and Records Administration (NARA) are the two heavyweight, information repositories in the United States. On a grand scale, these two organizations show the difference between a library and an archive.

The Library of Congress is first and foremost a research and legislative library for the U.S. Congress. It is the main copyright agency of the U.S. and one of the world’s greatest research centers, collecting materials across all disciplines. The library not only collects books, but it is also has the largest collection of maps, atlases, sheet music, recordings, tv shows and movies. Even though the library serves the U.S. Congress, it is also open to the general public.

The National Archives are tasked with preserving the history of the United States by managing federal records. They strive to save all important government records, safeguard the papers of every president since Herbert Hoover and set guidelines for preserving government records. The materials in their collections are focused on primary source materials, the stuff that historians use to write and make sense of our history.

National Archives, Credit: markcbrennan, Flickr

I’ve never made it out to either the LOC or NARA (which has branches throughout the U.S.) but I recently visited the NARA website to do some of my own research. I’m interested in the Office of Strategic Services (O.S.S.) the precursor to the C.I.A. which operated during World War II. The director of the OSS was Willam J. (“Wild Bill”) Donovan and his Director’s Office Files are kept on microfilm at NARA. Specifically, I want to see the documentation in the files on Poland during World War II and the Polish underground in particular. This set of records was fully declassified by the CIA in 2002.

Since I’m the one usually receiving and answering reference requests, it was a novel experience for me to send a question to the National Archives. We’ll see if I can get a hold of copies of these documents. Stay tuned…

What are Archives?

We’ve all heard about libraries, but what about archives? The main difference between the two is that libraries usually contain books and other published materials, while archives contain records, personal papers and all types of other unpublished materials.

I’m lucky since I get to work at both! This has caused an identity crisis for me, should I call myself a librarian or an archivist? Librarians are more familiar to people but I’m not just someone who says “Shhhh!” all the time! Archivist has a cool ring to it, but I have to explain what it means more often. I usually stick with librarian, since it’s something people can understand right away. I want to do my best to improve people’s perceptions of what it means to be a librarian.

Types of Archives

Archives can be public or private. Perhaps the largest archival repository in the world is the National Archives and Records Administration (NARA) which is an agency of the U.S. Government. The main branch of the National Archives is in College Park, Maryland but they also have 10 affiliated facilities and 14 regional facilities, that’s a lot of facilities! The Stanford University Archives or the Hoover Archives (where I work) are examples of private archives. Public archives are funded by national, state or local governments. Private archives can be funded by university endowments or private donors and collectors.

What They Collect

Each organization collects materials based on their mission. NARA collects government records and the papers of prominent civil servants, among many others. The Stanford Archives collect materials spanning several centuries, including first editions of famous literary works and the papers of Martin Luther King Jr. The Hoover Institution Archives’ collections relate to war, revolution and peace in the 20th and 21st centuries; yes it’s as awesome as it sounds and I’ll tell you more later.

Archives are fascinating because they contain the raw materials that scholars use to write books. Not all authors use archives to research their books, but most scholarly books with footnotes will refer to archival sources. Diaries, letters, photographs, records, sound recordings and film reels, held in archives, give us a glimpse into the past and help us to piece together the puzzle of history.

When Library Met Archives

One of the really cool parts of working at a the Hoover Institution Library and Archives, is to see the interplay between both types repositories. You can see how the raw historical material can be turned into a book or how the secondary source book, newspaper or magazine can lead a researcher back to the nitty gritty minutiae of an archival collection.

Recently I was giving a presentation about the Hoover Archives to a Stanford class. I showed them some original mug shots of Russian Bolshevik revolutionaries in our Okhrana collection, then I showed them the book written about one of the Bolsheviks, which was based on our collections (and which used a picture from our collection on the cover), and finally I pointed out the historian who wrote the book doing research right there in our reading room, how cool is that?!

Visit an Archive!

The whole idea of archives might be new to you, but believe me, even if you never plan on writing a PhD dissertation, it’s worth your time to check one out. Archives in the U.S. are very accessible and they are a lot more common than you think. Even the Redwood City Public Library (down the street from where I was born) has a local history room which includes an archive of photographs and other unique items that document the city’s history. Many archives will let you make photocopies or use your digital camera so you don’t have to do all of your research on the spot.

Now that I’ve explained how fascinating archives are, I hope you decide to visit one. If you want to visit an archive but can’t locate one in your area, drop me a line and I’ll help you.

Do you have any questions about what to expect in an archive? If you’ve been to an archive, what was your experience like?